Thanks for this discussion. I'd like to add a few notes and clarifications.
James Suckling left years ago to pursue new directions.
Matt Kramer left this summer. We regret that, but it was his decision.
James Laube has not left. He is no longer reviewing new release wines, but he will continue to write and taste for Wine Spectator.
Wine Spectator is not "on the wane." Despite headwinds in the publishing industry, our print circulation is solid, and our Web site has more traffic than any other wine site, to our knowledge. We feel we are still serving and pleasing our readers, and hope to continue doing so. We are always open to new ideas!
We value these Forums and thank members for their contributions. Basically, it's your world. I think Robert Taylor does an excellent job in terms of moderation, but generally we consider this a public square and encourage the free expression of your opinions about wine. You can make it a positive place, or not. Overall, we think the Forums serve a valuable purpose and we encourage you to make the most of them.