I had a conversation with a buddy who discounted the 1998 Fanti BdM (rated a 95WS) for the sole reason that the vintage was rated a 91. In fact, if you read the write up it starts with “Phenomenal for the vintage”.
So my question is….
Is a 1998 Brunello di Montalcino – rated a 95 (vintage rated a 91) better than a 1999 BdM rated a 92 – but from a better vintage?
Or is it a pure score vs score regardless of the vintage?