Skip to main content

I read this in WaPo yesterday and it really hit home.

https://www.washingtonpost.com...-care-tipping-point/


In the past several years almost every well-respected primary care physician in my area has either gone concierge or stopped taking on new patients. And it’s not just me; most people I know from elsewhere have wound up going concierge in order to keep their doctors in the past few years. My doctor wanted an absolutely insane amount of money to continue seeing her, so after looking around I found a doctor willing to take me on I think I like who “only” charges $2500 annually. But this really does seem like a growing problem. Is anyone else noticing this?

Last edited by winetarelli
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Same issue here.  I had a doc who I liked alot, but she quit to go work for the FDA. So, I started a process to try to find someone, and the only opportunity I could find was a concierge guy.  He "only" charges $1800 a year.
First appointment he canceled because he had laryngitis.  Second appointment canceled because he had torn his Achilles tendon and had to have surgery.  Did I get any money back? Of course not.  (He had someone covering for him).

Finally, I get in to see him.  We chat about stuff. This first meeting was just a "meet and greet."  At one point he says, "Let's talk about diet.  You know, the three meals a day thing is relatively new to mankind.  The cave men were hunter/gatherers, and did not eat breakfast.  Many people these days stop eating at 8 PM and don't eat anything else until noon."  I looked him in the eye and said, "Doc, have you seen any cavemen around lately?  Didn't work out so well for them did it?"  (My standard breakfast is no-fat yogurt, cheese, fruit and coffee....can't be that bad for you).

Then I get a real appointment with him, but first it is preceded by a meeting with a physician's assistant two weeks earlier.  She put me through a hearing test, measured my height and weight, took BP, checked some other stuff.  (Height went down, weight went up, but both marginally). Then she gave me three words to remember and said she'd ask me about them later in the appointment.  Then gave me a piece of paper and asked me to draw a clock with the hands pointing to 10 past 11.  Well, I can't draw.  At all.  I can barely draw a circle.  This was very stressful to me and took me fully 10 minutes to do.  She was staring at me.  (I should have looked at my watch for help, but didn't...I'll do that next time).  Ultimately,  I gave her the paper and then she asked me for the three words which, by this time, I had completely forgotten due to the stress of drawing the clock.  She measures my grip strength in my two hands.

Besides my inability to recall the three words, the only thing wrong was that my grip strength in my left hand (my non-dominant hand) was pretty diminished, compared to my right hand (the one I use for lifting glasses of wine).  I figure that won't kill me.

Then I see the doc two weeks later.  He mentions the grip strength and suggests perhaps I should get an MRI of my neck.  I said, "Well, I could do that but that won't help the grip strength will it?"  He says, "No. But it might tell us whether there is something wrong with my neck."  I said, "Well, let's suppose it shows that I have some significant neck issues on the MRI, but no symptoms but the decreased grip strength.  What then?"  He says, "Probably nothing."  I said, "Any other ideas?"  I had complained of pain in my left knee.  He said, "We could do an x-ray to see if you have arthritis in the left knee."  I said, "Doc, I'm 70. I'm sure I have arthritis in the left knee.  But, let's say the x-ray shows that I have alot of arthritis in the knee, then what?"  He says, "You'll be put on some anti-inflammatory medicine."  I said, "I already take that stuff."

What a great adventure.  And for $1800 a year!  Of course, they bill the medical insurance too.

And people look at me like I have a third arm growing out of my head when I say I want to move to Spain and get national healthcare for $200 a month. 

I'm not seeing the same problem you guys are here yet.  However, my recent impact I have seen multiple times.  Big companies buying up independent practices.  My primary finally decided to sell to WellMed about a year and a half ago.  He was going to stick around but is already gone.  The PA I was assigned to see in his absence is already gone so my next appointment has been delayed because the replacement PA is backed up because the last left unannounced.  I guess I could switch to 1 of the 2 primaries in my immediate area instead.  Wait, one isn't accepting new patients.  But there is a WellMed closer to my house who bought out the third primary in my area.

I switched to a concierge doctor this year.  Was able to get on his list because a doctor friend of mine made a call and was able to convince him to take me. 

My previous primary care doctor was becoming impossible to see - it was rare for the office to pick up ("leave a message and we will return your call") and difficult to book an appointment.  I was using urgent care facilities for any medical issues.  Having a concierge doctor took care of that problem.

While I am not thrilled to be paying a concierge fee, I must say that the level of attention I get is fantastic.  I have the doctor's phone number and if I text him he returns the text or calls me almost immediately.  I can get in to see him usually same day or at least next day.  Prescription calls are immediate.

I will be re-upping next year.



  Big companies buying up independent practices.  My primary finally decided to sell to WellMed about a year and a half ago.  He was going to stick around but is already gone.  The PA I was assigned to see in his absence is already gone so my next appointment has been delayed because the replacement PA is backed up because the last left unannounced.  I guess I could switch to 1 of the 2 primaries in my immediate area instead.  Wait, one isn't accepting new patients.  But there is a WellMed closer to my house who bought out the third primary in my area.

I used to go to a local clinic that had several locations. They've been losing doctors for years. Then they were bought out by Optimum a couple years ago. Quality went down, wait time went up. Then they tried to jack up the rates to my county gov't insurance, which led to my insurance refusing to renew their contract. That went on for a few months until they settled into an agreement. Then the other day the local paper announced a large number of surprise layoffs to their staff. People who'd worked there 15+ years were just told one day to pack up their stuff and be prepared to be escorted out the door.

I saw the writing on the wall last year, and went with another outfit. Not as convenient with less locations, but at least my primary seems to listen to me.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×