Skip to main content

quote:
Originally posted by bman:
quote:
Originally posted by wine+art:
Barney's Version


This film did very well at the Genie Awards, Canada's Oscars, but of course I haven't seen it here. What did you think?



bman, a very well executed movie and intelligent by design. Now that said, not too sure how enjoyable it is overall.

As you know, Giamatti holds both an undergrad and a Masters degree from Yale, where his father also taught.

This is not a movie for the simple minded, or the indolent in life, and one must be somewhat benevolent and magnanimous while viewing.

As you noted, this is a Mordecai Richler screenplay. Wink
Inside Job

meh. when documentaries are so blatantly one-sided, they lose all credibility IMO. i'm in no means in support of what happened, but when you take such a blatant stance on a subject, it's all too easy to call your entire message into doubt.

i liken it to someone raising their voice during an argument. if your point can't stand on its own, it probably isn't a very solid point to begin with.
quote:
Originally posted by jorgerunfast:
Inside Job

meh. when documentaries are so blatantly one-sided, they lose all credibility IMO. i'm in no means in support of what happened, but when you take such a blatant stance on a subject, it's all too easy to call your entire message into doubt.

i liken it to someone raising their voice during an argument. if your point can't stand on its own, it probably isn't a very solid point to begin with.


I agree but it is always important to get another version of what really happened than the 'official' version.
quote:
Originally posted by wine+art:
quote:
Originally posted by bman:
quote:
Originally posted by wine+art:
Barney's Version


This film did very well at the Genie Awards, Canada's Oscars, but of course I haven't seen it here. What did you think?



bman, a very well executed movie and intelligent by design. Now that said, not too sure how enjoyable it is overall.

As you know, Giamatti holds both an undergrad and a Masters degree from Yale, where his father also taught.

This is not a movie for the simple minded, or the indolent in life, and one must be somewhat benevolent and magnanimous while viewing.

As you noted, this is a Mordecai Richler screenplay. Wink


What a Loser.......

I'm watching this: 2+2 is Four!!
quote:
Originally posted by Cellar_Fiend:
quote:
Originally posted by wine+art:
quote:
Originally posted by bman:
quote:
Originally posted by wine+art:
Barney's Version


This film did very well at the Genie Awards, Canada's Oscars, but of course I haven't seen it here. What did you think?



bman, a very well executed movie and intelligent by design. Now that said, not too sure how enjoyable it is overall.

As you know, Giamatti holds both an undergrad and a Masters degree from Yale, where his father also taught.

This is not a movie for the simple minded, or the indolent in life, and one must be somewhat benevolent and magnanimous while viewing.

As you noted, this is a Mordecai Richler screenplay. Wink


What a Loser.......

I'm watching this: 2+2 is Four!!


Oh my, you clearly are not well-read. Frown

Try reading Richler, and just perhaps the obvious irony and mockery would be seen. Roll Eyes
The Men Who Stare at Goats -- strange and somewhat interesting; not terrible but can't say it was good either

Internationally Speaking -- documentary about what others in foreign countries think about the U.S. and its foreign policies. Could have been an interesting movie if the filmmaker hadn't taken such a one-sided, liberal approach. I lean toward liberal, but this movie was so slanted it was silly.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×