Skip to main content

quote:
Originally posted by MJAlbers:
quote:
Originally posted by gigabit:
quote:
Originally posted by wine+art:
Phillip Seymour Hoffman's work. Smile

The finest living American actor, imo.
Agreed! Always great when playing a character who's name ends in Y!
Scotty- Boogie Nights
Freddy- The Talented Mr. Ripley
Sandy- Along Came Polly


PSH is, indeed, a terrific actor.

But greatest living, I respectfully dissagree.

While some of these guys seem to have been phoning it in for the past 15 years, and he may be in the same league as (some of) these guys, for me, it is hard to he is deffinitely better than:

Dustin Hoffman
Robert DeNiro
Al Pacino
Harvey Keitel
Gene Hackman
Denzel Washington
Russell Crowe
Johnny Depp
Sean Penn
Ian McKellan
John Hurt
Leonardo DiCaprio
Morgan Freeman
Gary Oldman
Jack Nicholson

And, to me, the one who is completely in a league of his own:

Daniel Day Lewis
quote:
Originally posted by winetarelli:
PSH is, indeed, a terrific actor.

But greatest living, I respectfully dissagree.

While some of these guys seem to have been phoning it in for the past 15 years, and he may be in the same league as (some of) these guys, for me, it is hard to he is deffinitely better than:

Dustin Hoffman
Robert DeNiro
Al Pacino
Harvey Keitel
Gene Hackman
Denzel Washington
Russell Crowe
Johnny Depp
Sean Penn
Ian McKellan
John Hurt
Leonardo DiCaprio
Morgan Freeman
Gary Oldman
Jack Nicholson


And, to me, the one who is completely in a league of his own:

Daniel Day Lewis

winetarelli,

There are some great talents on this list, but Leonardo DiCaprio?!!! Confused

Here is how I would sum them up:

Dustin Hoffman
Robert DeNiro
Al Pacino
Harvey Keitel
Gene Hackman
Jack Nicholson

Unfortunately, all way past their prime.

Denzel Washington
Russell Crowe
Ian McKellan
John Hurt
Morgan Freeman
Gary Oldman

Not quite good enough...

Johnny Depp
Sean Penn

Very close...

Daniel Day Lewis

Equal, but not an American. Wink
quote:
Originally posted by gigabit:
quote:
Originally posted by winetarelli:
PSH is, indeed, a terrific actor.

But greatest living, I respectfully dissagree.

While some of these guys seem to have been phoning it in for the past 15 years, and he may be in the same league as (some of) these guys, for me, it is hard to he is deffinitely better than:

Dustin Hoffman
Robert DeNiro
Al Pacino
Harvey Keitel
Gene Hackman
Denzel Washington
Russell Crowe
Johnny Depp
Sean Penn
Ian McKellan
John Hurt
Leonardo DiCaprio
Morgan Freeman
Gary Oldman
Jack Nicholson


And, to me, the one who is completely in a league of his own:

Daniel Day Lewis

winetarelli,

There are some great talents on this list, but Leonardo DiCaprio?!!! Confused

Here is how I would sum them up:

Dustin Hoffman
Robert DeNiro
Al Pacino
Harvey Keitel
Gene Hackman
Jack Nicholson

Unfortunately, all way past their prime.

Denzel Washington
Russell Crowe
Ian McKellan
John Hurt
Morgan Freeman
Gary Oldman

Not quite good enough...

Johnny Depp
Sean Penn

Very close...

Daniel Day Lewis

Equal, but not an American. Wink


Well... we can agree to dissagree... Though I do agree with you that most in your first list haven't given a great performance in awhile.

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio. Believe me, I hate that I have to include him in the list. Hate it. But, honestly, he is by far the best actor of his generation... or seems to be. He was truly incredible in The Aviator.
quote:
Originally posted by wine+art:
Many excellent actors listed above for sure.

I would add Forest Whitaker to the list, and also agree DiCaprio is rock solid and moving towards the elite status soon.

Anyone that knows me, knows I hold Winetarelli in very high regard. Now that said ,( Wink) Winetarelli, you do know females can act as well! Razz Big Grin

Javier Bardem has really burst onto the scene in the past couple of years. I predict even better things for him in the future.

(Watch The Sea Inside if you haven't seen it yet)

I would also add (off the top of my head):

Tom Wilkinson
William H. Macy
John Turturro
Ralph Fiennes
David Strathairn
John C. Reilly
Tom Hanks
Jamie Foxx
Robert Downey Jr.
Anthony Hopkins

As for the women...

Judi Dench
Kate Winslet
Tilda Swinton
Frances McDormand
etc...

However, they all worship at the feet of Meryl Streep.
quote:
Originally posted by wine+art:
Many excellent actors listed above for sure.

I would add Forest Whitaker to the list, and also agree DiCaprio is rock solid and moving towards the elite status soon.

Anyone that knows me, knows I hold Winetarelli in very high regard. Now that said ,( Wink) Winetarelli, you do know females can act as well! Razz Big Grin


Yeah, I was keeping it just men and, while I agree with you about Forest Whitaker, it is ironic that he is who you mentioned, as he beat someone else for his Oscar whom I deffinitely should have mentioned -- Peter O'Toole.

Apart from Daniel Day Lewis, there is no better living actor, male or female, than Meryl Streep, of course!

Others I like:
Maggie Smith
Imelda Staunton
Judi Dench
Helen Mirren
Emma Thompson
Kate Winslet
(are you seeing a pattern?)

Also,

Jodi Foster
Holly Hunter

BUT, the best performance I saw last year was Viola Davis in Doubt. I had just never even heard of her before.
Saw Watchmen last Saturday. I saw some scathing reviews by people who are apparently die-hard fans of the comic. I never read it, so I can't say if it's better or worse. Definately an adult take on the superhero genre, though. So if you're thinking of taking a kid, be advised there is full frontal male nudity and some fairly graphic sex scenes.
quote:
Originally posted by mneeley490:
Saw Watchmen last Saturday. I saw some scathing reviews by people who are apparently die-hard fans of the comic. I never read it, so I can't say if it's better or worse. Definately an adult take on the superhero genre, though. So if you're thinking of taking a kid, be advised there is full frontal male nudity and some fairly graphic sex scenes.


Is there any full frontal female nudity? Big Grin
quote:
Originally posted by mneeley490:
Saw Watchmen last Saturday. I saw some scathing reviews by people who are apparently die-hard fans of the comic. I never read it, so I can't say if it's better or worse. Definately an adult take on the superhero genre, though. So if you're thinking of taking a kid, be advised there is full frontal male nudity and some fairly graphic sex scenes.
Sold! I'm not a die-hard fan, though I did read and very much enjoyed the novel, and definitely am aiming to see the movie this weekend. The thought seems to be that the director stayed almost too true to the original writing, which in turn did not translate particularly well to the screen. In any event I'm very excited to see it.
quote:
Originally posted by wineismylife:
quote:
Originally posted by mneeley490:
Saw Watchmen last Saturday. I saw some scathing reviews by people who are apparently die-hard fans of the comic. I never read it, so I can't say if it's better or worse. Definately an adult take on the superhero genre, though. So if you're thinking of taking a kid, be advised there is full frontal male nudity and some fairly graphic sex scenes.


Is there any full frontal female nudity? Big Grin

Sadly, no.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×