I used to enjoy this show. Some of the production (and Alton Brown and his crony) was annoying but the judges were usually pretty legitimate and it wasn't too "reality tv-ish".
I recently dvr'd an episode because it had one my favorite chefs (Mike Lata of Charleston's "Fig"). Come to find out the secret ingredient was "sparkling wine" (three choices: champagne, "california style sparkling wine" and prosseco) which made me even more excited.
Well the show has gotten beyond bad. The judges had zero critical comments it was "this is amazing" and "best bite I've ever had". One of the judges was a joke. I couldn't tell if it was even serious or not. He was the creative director of Barneys (however you spell the clothing store) if you're curious. Theatrics were out of control as well. I could handle them earlier but no longer. RIP Iron Chef America.
Original Post