Skip to main content

A dinner at my house in Beaune last summer: Wines here

the list from left to right:

- Coudoulet de Beaucastel (rouge) 1999
- Puligny Montrachet 1° cru les Referts J.M. Boillot 2001
- Mas Amiel Vintage blanc 2001
- Champagne Jacquesson cuvée 728
- Mas Amiel "Plenitude" Maccabeu 2001
- Bandol Rosé "Chateau de Pibarnon" 2002
- Muscat St Jean de Minervois

The menu:

1/ Apéritif
2/ Gaspacho
3/ Aiguillettes de dinde aux citrons et asperges vertes
4/ Fromages
5/ Desserts:
-Sorbet fraise
-Cramble abricot pommes amandes
-Cerises de l'arbre...
-Fraises
-Brownies
It's in french... (otherwise too easy)
Put the right wine to the right place! Good luck! Cool
Last edited {1}
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Thanks for the information on Mas Amiel. I have not seen it here, and wonder if it is imported to the US.
Well, this is a great deal of dessert wine. I would now say that, depending on the type of cheese, the Mas Amiel would go with the cheese. Yes, the cheese, particularly if it is powerful cheeses, like Epoisse or Rocquefort.
Now, the Rose moves up to go with the Champagne as the aperetif wine. Or maybe the Mas Amiel just goes with the desserts.
I think there is a lot of powerful dessert wines here, and alot of desserts.
It's very difficult to drink Mas Amiel "vintage"or "Macabeu" with cheese for a "french taste" and you are right they well match with desserts (especially chocolate), the muscat "St Jean de Minervois" of course too.
For the rest, you made mistakes... (the game is not over)
I wonder if I am not going to send you one bottle of Mas Amiel Cool because you are the only one interested with my little game.
So if you want to send me your adress... (I am not kidding!)
1/ Apéritif
Muscat St Jean de Minervois

2/ Gaspacho
Bandol Rosé "Chateau de Pibarnon" 2002

3/ Aiguillettes de dinde aux citrons et asperges vertes
Puligny Montrachet 1° cru les Referts J.M. Boillot 2001

4/ Fromages
Coudoulet de Beaucastel (rouge) 1999

5/ Desserts:
-Sorbet fraise
-Cramble abricot pommes amandes
Mas Amiel Vintage blanc 2001

-Cerises de l'arbre...
I would think you had 1 of those wines with the cerises and another dessert, maybe the Amiel Vintage blanc?
-Fraises
Champagne Jacquesson cuvée 728

-Brownies
Mas Amiel "Plenitude" Maccabeu 2001

How close am I ? Smile
Jean Eric:
I'd love to receive a bottle from you, but the cost would be too high for you, plus it is illegal in the state I live in (Maryland) to receive wine shipments. Therefore, I must decline your kind offer.
(Il est illégal de recevoir le vin par cette manière dans mon état du Maryland--Par conséquent, je dois refuser votre offre aimable).
I will look for the Mas Amiel at our local stores.

OK--My next guess:

1/ Apéritif--The Champagne
2/ Gaspacho--The Rose
3/ Aiguillettes de dinde aux citrons et asperges vertes--the C de B
4/ Fromages--the Puligny Montrachet
5/ Desserts:
-Sorbet fraise
-Cramble abricot pommes amandes
-Cerises de l'arbre...
-Fraises
-Brownies
Avec les desserts, toute l'autres.
quote:
Originally posted by irwin:
Jean Eric:
I'd love to receive a bottle from you, but the cost would be too high for you, plus it is illegal in the state I live in (Maryland) to receive wine shipments. Therefore, I must decline your kind offer.
(Il est illégal de recevoir le vin par cette manière dans mon état du Maryland--Par conséquent, je dois refuser votre offre aimable).
I will look for the Mas Amiel at our local stores.

OK--My next guess:

1/ Apéritif--The Champagne
2/ Gaspacho--The Rose
3/ Aiguillettes de dinde aux citrons et asperges vertes--the C de B
4/ Fromages--the Puligny Montrachet
5/ Desserts:
-Sorbet fraise
-Cramble abricot pommes amandes
-Cerises de l'arbre...
-Fraises
-Brownies
Avec les desserts, toute l'autres.


You won! But with just one mistake.
The cheese was a "Citeaux" (I did not tell you...) and the C.B. matched well with it, believe me!
And the Puligny Montrachet 1° cru???
As always or often in Burgundy for APERITIF!
Some white wines "live" by themselves so why eat something with them? It's no necessary.
Another example, we frequently drink "Montrachet" for apéritif, or just with a piece of Comté, that's all. You know, when you see "a lord", you have to honor him and in general great wine are very "egoïst". You can extend this for a lot of white wines 1° cru.
But I am sure you do that too in USA. If it's the case, you are right.


Bravo for you and ArieS, he was close too!

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×