Originally posted by Golf&Pinot Nut:
This is a consistently great wine. Just ask yourself if its worth that much to you. At this price, I think you have to ask yourself, "Self, do you want the Insignia or the Shafer Hillside?"
That's an easy decision for me.
Very well said! Also, I can find the Insignia most anywhere, while it is very difficult to find the Hillside Select, unless you're on their mailing list, and even then, it is limited. Still, the prices are about the same (actually, the Insignia costs more in this market).
Your comparison has clarified the issue. I'll take the Shafer Hilliside Select!