WS rates this a 91, but to me it's a disappointment compared to the '03 and especially '02 versions. Perhaps I had an off bottle, but it's much too woody, tons of oak that overpowers the vanilla and cherry. No score, as I'll try another bottle first. I've loved this QPR, and hope I won't have to scrounge up '02s and '03s until the '05s come out. $17 Costco.