Skip to main content

Tried this wine again for the 3rd time. The first two times, I was perplexed because the wine was thin, closed and had nothing going for it. I just could not understand the low 90's rating.

Last night, the wine opened up a little more, but it had a grapey zin-like nose and flavor. Still very simple and not very attractive.

Of the 30 cases of 97 California Cabs that I bought based on the WS California issue that focused on the 97's, IMO 1/3 were rated correctly, 1/3 were rated high and 1/3 were rated way too high. When a 97 BV Tapestry (a good wine that I like) is rated within 1 point of a 97 Screaming Eagle (which is in a different class), I guess I should have taken the rest of the advice with a grain of salt.

Although I am a big supporter of WS, the erratic ratings of California cabs is not representative of the high quality of the rest of the magazine.
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

LCC and KOH, I have had the 94 and 96 and I thought they were very good wines. Since I'm the one who is always saying that we drink our wines too young, I should be more patient. The wine improved a lot last night (2nd day). It is still not what anywhere near the 94 or 96 bottles or what it was rated.

I guess the main concern I have is I believe JL tends to overrate wines that show well early. When he rates a wine pretty high and it does not show well early, I get concerned. I guess if I assume that he rated it the same way he did the Schweiger

Maybe the 97 will improve and reach the level of the 94 or 96. I guess only time will tell.

DrT, don't remind me of the Lokoya. I only bought one bottle and I paid a premium for it. I also bought 3 cases of the BV GDL at $69.95 a bottle. I was assuming that these fell into the "slightly overrated" category.

I got really sucked in when I saw the nice glossy cover for that Big CA issue with the bottles of the great wines. I even took the next day off and drove to Napa (before the wineries were open) and filled up my car. What a mistake.

Add Reply

Link copied to your clipboard.