This is a gorgeous champagne. At 15 years post vintage It is creamy from beginning to end with a smoky profile. Toasted brioche with baked apple and a a pleasing roasted mushroom component. The length of the finish on this is very long. After drinking this, it makes me want to get back into working with Charlier get into the US market so champagne lovers here in the USA can discover what they are all about. 94-95 points. if you are traveling in Europe and find any vintage of this special club buy it and bring it back. You will not be disappointed.