Reply to "Stephen Strasburg being shut down"

quote:
Originally posted by wine+art:
I'm with PH and TPE.

Based on the way the Nats have used him, I shut him down, no question.

This said, I would have thought much like TPE stated, you could have given him more skipped starts throughout the season and this would not have been an issue.


I'm no doctor, and certainly not a baseball expert, but I've heard enough reasonable arguments against skipping starts by serious baseball guys to not see this as an option. There's a rhythm of rest and activity that seems to work well for starters in the bigs, and the risk of long lapses between throwing hard in a game situation could put him at increased risk. Again, we have four SERIOUS starters to carry on with the season.

I commend Mike Rizzo and the Nat's management for making a prudent and LONG TERM decision on the fate of this young man. He's a phenom, and entitled to a chance at a long career. To go against the preponderence of medical opinion in the short term run for a title this year would exemplify everything that is bad and short sighted about sports in America.

PH
×
×
×
×