Vinorave - one other thing to keep in mind is that nobody is able to forseee the future. Those suggestions for drinking windows are best guesses based on prior experience, and may be as close as anyone can get, but they are not written in stone. Your personal preferences matter a lot more than someone's suggestion. In addition, the suggestion may simply be wrong. Nobody is trying to mislead you, but some people are more optomistic than others, and other people like older wines with whispers of flavors that other people would find over the hill.