I'm confused what the over $100 price has to do with anything. A $30 wine (wholesale) does not guarantee anything, does it?
TT, if the bottle was showing well to you, that is all that really matters.
I only pointed out the price to show that it wasn't a cheap wine.
And you're right about what it showed to me is what matters. It was just odd that the wine I had showed very well to me and more so than wines rated in the 90 point range.
The WS online doesn't show a rating for the 2005 Faust