First of all, I would chose Scala's over Kuleto's for Italian-esque Union Square dining in this price range. (Bonus: last time I was there they charged very low corkage - I think $12/bottle.)
Though, to be honest, for great Italian dining I would walk the extra blocks and eat at Perbacco.
That being said, to answer your question, from that list, I would order the '04 Sandrone Barbera without a second thought. IIRC, I have scored that wine between 91.5 and 94 points.