Went to Total Wine today and picked up these:
Chappellet Signature Cab 2011
Avenel Cellars Napa Cab 2010
Dom des Versauds Morgon 2011
I basically wrote down some recommendations from here and showed it to the guy and asked for some help. He said the Chappellet was easily the best they had in the store under $60. I think I'm going to save that for Christmas.
I forget the story on the Avenel and the Dom was his recommendation when I said I'd like to try the Ste Michelle. Will try to still pick some of that up, but I'm curious about his recommendation, too.