WineSpectator.com    Wine Spectator Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Wine Conversations    How to buy a great bottle safely
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
How to buy a great bottle safely
 Login/Join 
Member
posted
I buy a lot of mid level wines $30-$70 but I'd like to get a couple of special bottles of Bordeaux but I'm concerned how to buy old wines and ensure I get a bottle in good condition. I'm not looking at first growths but maybe a 2000 2nd or 3rd etc maybe $200-$400.

How do I ensure I get genuine wine in good condition
 
Posts: 540 | Location: Chicago | Registered: Aug 27, 2009Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
posted Hide Post
welshstar,

While no one can guarantee you a bottle of wine is not tainted, you do want to seek out a bottle from solid provenance.

When buying a bottle as common as what you are looking for, I would buy/trade from a friend that bought 2000 Bordeaux on release and has a proper cellar, or perhaps seek a bottle from someone on this forum that is near you.

What city are you in?
 
Posts: 30128 | Location: Dallas, TX & Santa Fe, NM | Registered: Feb 21, 2005Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
posted Hide Post
Two ways to obtain such wines safely.
Reputable retailer or reputable auction house.

A good retailer is likely to have such bottles available and likely to store and protect such bottles in temperature controlled environments. If the bottle is faulty, they would also be likely to replace or refund. Among big reputable retailers, I would consider JJ Buckley, Zachy's, Premier Cru, Sokolin.

A reputable auction house usually does their best to screen: check provenance and bottle condition. Price is usually adjusted accordingly. While there is rarely refund for faulty bottles, the more reputable auction houses try to pre-screen. I would also include internet auction houses like Winebid in addition to the big houses.

With all of that said, as far as getting a fake bottle, it would be unusual for counterfeiters to create fake second growth bottles. The counterfeit action is usually with aged first growth Bordeaux and Grand Cru Burgundy.
 
Posts: 1607 | Location: Pacific Palisades, CA | Registered: Feb 10, 2011Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
posted Hide Post
Hi

I live in Chicago so nt bad there.

I'm sure it's unusual but I bought a few bottles of Carlisle from hdh and they were very highly rated but on drinking they were very disapointing enough that they had obviously not been stored correctly at some point. I know hdh is very reputable so it was not them at fault but how do you know it was stored right before they got it ?
 
Posts: 540 | Location: Chicago | Registered: Aug 27, 2009Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by welshstar:
Hi

I live in Chicago so nt bad there.

I'm sure it's unusual but I bought a few bottles of Carlisle from hdh and they were very highly rated but on drinking they were very disapointing enough that they had obviously not been stored correctly at some point. I know hdh is very reputable so it was not them at fault but how do you know it was stored right before they got it ?


Not sure why they were 'disappointing' or why that disappointment led you to believe they had been improperly stored. Were they 'cooked', with a stewed, raisiny flavor?

This is a very good thread describing the impact of improper storage.

Bottom line: you pays your money and you takes your chances. Even with a reputable house like HDH or TCWC, there is still an element of risk.
 
Posts: 2799 | Location: Toronto | Registered: Nov 30, 2009Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
posted Hide Post
They weren't corked but they did have a stewed characteristic that you mentioned. I'm not an expert but I've had a lot of Syrah from that area and it was bitter and hot, maybe that is a sign of corked
 
Posts: 540 | Location: Chicago | Registered: Aug 27, 2009Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
posted Hide Post
Ha! No, bitter and hot is how Syrah tastes when it's overdone (think Aussie Shiraz).

Welshstar- if you're interested in a bottle of 2000 Pichon Longueville Baron I have plenty. I came upon it at a good price. If it's that meaningful to you I'd be happy to give you a fair price. I live in Chicago, the wine has been in my cellar since delivery so I can guarantee it is all stored as well as I store all my wine. Beyond that I can give no guarantees- if it's corked that's not my responsibility.

I will also tell you that I have no intention of opening this wine with good expectations for another 5 years or so. Last I had it was summer of 2010 and I could tell it needed a lot more time.

If you're interested post in this thread with your email address. If not, that's ok too, you don't know me, my feelings won't be hurt!


*******
Go Habs Go
 
Posts: 5564 | Location: Chicago | Registered: May 24, 2002Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Member
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by grossie:
Ha! No, bitter and hot is how Syrah tastes when it's overdone (think Aussie Shiraz).

Welshstar- if you're interested in a bottle of 2000 Pichon Longueville Baron I have plenty. I came upon it at a good price. If it's that meaningful to you I'd be happy to give you a fair price. I live in Chicago, the wine has been in my cellar since delivery so I can guarantee it is all stored as well as I store all my wine. Beyond that I can give no guarantees- if it's corked that's not my responsibility.

I will also tell you that I have no intention of opening this wine with good expectations for another 5 years or so. Last I had it was summer of 2010 and I could tell it needed a lot more time.

If you're interested post in this thread with your email address. If not, that's ok too, you don't know me, my feelings won't be hurt!



Pretty sweet offer and a terrific bottle of wine. I agree 5+ yrs to go and it might be entering its drinking window at that point IMO.


-------------

Say NO to Shiraz!
 
Posts: 2756 | Registered: Nov 07, 2007Reply With QuoteReport This Post
  Powered by Social Strata  
 

WineSpectator.com    Wine Spectator Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Wine Conversations    How to buy a great bottle safely

© Wine Spectator 2013