I have no qualms with that; this guy deserves this and more. Basic summary of the discussion (quotes are actual excerpts):
stickman: Despite the fact that the description said this bottle was in perfect condition, the capsule has been completely removed, and there is a leakage stain at the top of the cork. I'd like to return the bottle for a refund.
seller: That stain is probably from the wax capsule, not wine.
stickman: The wax was red; this is purple. Definitely not a wax stain.
seller: I don't believe it; show me.
stickman: [sends two digital images via email]
seller: "So some wine ran up a cork while the bottle was in repose. I have hundreds of bottles like that and never has it affected the contents... Stop whining."
stickman: I'm very disappointed in your response. I will contact winecommune about this.
seller: "just to make you go away, I'll take the bottle back for a $50 'hassle' fee and you return it two day service" [fwiw, it was originally shipped 3-day service]
stickman: You want to make a profit from lying to me? 'Sorry, not playing that game.
seller: "You're an idiot."
seller = andykossin2
Unfortunately, my contact at winecommune was very polite but refused to take any action.

Chalk it up to a lesson learned... a very expensive lesson, to be sure.
De gustibus non est disputandum.