I've heard some buzz on this one, and a local shop has it for $85 a bottle.

Convince me.

Haven't had the 2005 yet. I thought the 1994 was excellent. The 2002 was $35/bottle and pretty good for the price. I wouldn't pay $85/bottle for either vintage. I would like to here about the 2005 as well although I suspect it will be good but not worth the asking price based on the past vintages I've tried.